There are not many that can do this while meeting certain criteria that are inseparable from a survival resolution. The answer to all these reflections then came a compact G17 … the Glock 19. I don’t care which is better for concealed carry. Both are capable of far more accuracy than I (and probably you) are able to extract from them. One of the most critical aspects of a handgun is its accuracy. After trying many many different pistols, My personal favorite is the G19, Gen 3. I did own one Glock in .45 ACP, but found the grip too large for my hands. The role of a weapon, and especially a handgun, is a critical situation where we find ourselves back to the wall. A firearm should be able to be hidden easily, without losing some ability to stop a target when fired. Glock vs M1911 comparison. The barrel length of the Glock 17 is at 4.5 inches and measures 8 inches long on overall. So, in conclusion, I agree. This situation of life and death requires the use of a tool that works at the right time. And i will choose and byu G19. The two guns are the same width (1.26 inches) and the same distance from the back of the slide to the ejection port. Price not being an option. All that said, however, concealed carry is more of an art form than a science, and the size of your gun is only one factor in being able to conceal it well. It makes no sense to design your self-defense strategy around how many times you are going to miss. Trigger pull is the same 5.5 pounds for the same pistols, and trigger travel is the same .49 inches. Let’s get some basics out of the way, for those of you who are new to this debate. As a gunsmith, I checked it over, and everything looked good. Any action necessary to prepare the weapon to be fired, and any action required after the shooting must be able to be performed with one hand, either the left or the right. Each model denotes a specific frame size and caliber. No more than 20 defective operations are allowed during the first 10,000 shots, not even the simplest failures. Simpker = better? Archived. If you are using your Glock for certain types of competition, for instance, and are actually going to fire a whole magazine at once, it makes sense to go for the larger magazine. I personally am not in a situation where I could legally concele carry a handgun (living in California). The weapon must be perfectly secure against accidental discharges due to shocks and falls from a height of 2 meters on a steel plate. For outdoors excursions in Grizzly bear territory, I carried a Stainless Steel RANDALL Govt in .45 SUPER, with a 6″ ramped and coned barrel. It is simply THE BEST … FOR ME. 4. The G26, even with HOT 9MM NATO BALL ammo, was inclined to failures if limp wristed. When you first pick them up, the size of the two guns is the most obvious difference. Glock 17 is slightly heavier as compared to Glock 19. Thank you Ken, what do you sell the 17 & 19 for. The debate of the caliber is we’re afraid to say, endless.

’Glock













Both of these guns can be concealed well. !Glock Pistol Spec. BAD BEARS BEWARE. SO, Glock likes to brag about “PERFECTION”. At the range, which of the two do you find to be most accurate? Well, you may know by now that the Glock 19 is our top choice. If you are lucky enough to live in a hot climate, where thin shirts are commonplace, pistol grips are typically more at risk of printing than barrels, and for this reason the Glock 19 is preferable in these situations. I gave up serious pistol competition, but still enjoyed delusions of being capable of protecting myself with a pistol, if necessary, from man or beast. Well, maybe. I opted to stick with the Glock rail and the non-ambi mag release. The best gun is the one you are used to, can rely on, and have practiced for many hours with. Despite initial market resistance due to some concerns primarily about the durability and reliability of a “plastic” firearm. Glock 19 whereas possessing 19 bullets round-up capacity. One of which, concelabilitey. But, following that logic, you might as well get an assault rifle. For maximum reliability with 9MM, I swapped in .9mm extractors, ejectors, and magazines, but experimenting with .40 slides combined with an after market 9mm conversipn barrel, no other changes, proved quite reliable. My question is, do we have the option to carry the Glock 19 which is a smaller pistol and fits my small hands, have better control, etc. But, however, he did have a mastery of synthetic polymer products, and developed the first weapon made of “plastic.”. Ordering parts after troubleshooting your VP9 is quite the hassle, to say the least. In addition, when using extended length magazines in the shorter grips of the G26 and G19, the magazines may not be supported adequately, so failures to feed are more likely. Both of these are excellent firearms. If we wanna use micro Roni whos the best? There is an area in which the different sizes of the two guns makes a real difference, though, and that is in concealed carry. No review can ever recommend the perfect handgun. No, he qualified his decision the 19 is better based on certain criteria. He more than answered the question. The Glock 19 comes with two 15-round stock mags while the Glock 23 comes with two 13-round stock mags. Its ergonomics fit both a woman’s hand and a man’s hand, and the 9mm caliber makes it easily tamed by most of us. The attributes of each model make them look different in terms of performance and general usability.Starting with the size, you will get the Glock 17 being longer and taller. Sig 226/229 vs Glock 17/19 ? Glock 17 has a larger barrel of 114mm. I put a set of Talon grips on it, and of everything I’ve owned so far, this firearm is the most accurate. The G19 with a standard charger has a capacity of 15 cartridges. Ok, now we get into the real differences between the guns. The survivalist’s handgun must not only be extremely reliable, robust, and efficient. This current comparison is much ado about nothing but preference…go to a range and shoot both and select…who knows, you may not like a Glock at all. This trait is shared with its stablemate the G20. The 19 model, on the other hand, has a shorter barrel at just 4 inches. The half-inch that has been shaved off the Glock 19’s grip makes carrying it concealed a lot easier than that number, on paper, would indicate. I found the G34, with the longer sight radius, significantly more accurate at longer ranges, but also significantly slower at close range quick and dirty stages. Simple, reliable, robust, and regardless of the model chosen, the Glock is undoubtedly a handgun that deserves special attention for the survivalist. Why choose? Glock 19 has a shorter barrel of 102mm. This means that it is classified as a compact, and not a full-sized pistol.Beyond this, the guns are actually very similar. If I could only choose and have one of these guns, I would take the Glock 21. But mostly, I used it for bowling pin matches. The Glocks (17 and 19) were thrown off a plane, dragged behind a car for miles, immersed in mud for months, etc. The G19 is a G17 that fits perfectly with all the criteria of the survivalist. I read many, many gun articles about short barrel handguns, both revolver and semi-auto. Posted by 2 years ago. For years, both have been proven effective for self defense . The Glock 22 is what you get when you design the Glock 17 to use 40 caliber ammo. However, If I ever wanted another .45 Super pistol, next time I would probably build it on Glock instead of a 1911. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. This was especially noticeable during long strings, at multiple targets. The G19X comes in a standard Glock box, but in a different desert tan color, which according to Glock is called the Coyote. I’m sure it is possible, through a series of handler errors, to make them seize up, but for most people most of the time both guns are as reliable as it gets. Yes your assumption is correct, lasers and/or flashlights can be attached to both models. Model: G17 Gen4. The GLOCK 19 is billed as being better for people with smaller hands, but only marginally so; the trigger reach (the distance from the back of the pistol grip to the front face of the trigger) is only 0.03 inches longer on the GLOCK 17 vs GLOCK 19. In discussions of which is the better gun, much is made of the fact that the Glock 17 has a bigger ammunition magazine than the 19. I have no experience with the G17 but if it’s ½ the gun the G19 is, then you can’t go wrong with either one imho. With the weapon, we also have two chargers, an operation manual, and a brush to clean it. The G17 is all yours for the taking. The Glock 17 and the Glock 19 are, essentially, the same gun, except that the Glock 19 has a slightly smaller barrel and grip. The non-ambi mag release because then my older 21 mags work in my new SF. On the other hand, it accepts the chargers of its big brother the G17, and can, therefore, be of a capacity that exceeds 15 rounds. we are glad you are here ! I had a 21; bought a 21SF to replace it because it fits my hand better. This is a very tough call, but I think the 19 wins very narrowly for concealability. Let’s take a look at the main points of similarity and difference between the guns, and why you would choose one over the other. In truth, though, this will make very little difference unless you are shooting in competition, and also adds some weight to the gun. Glock G17 Gen4 . I imagine these are the same people who, in that situation, will fire off their whole magazine in two seconds, and maybe hit once. Chargers must have a minimum capacity of 8 balls. But, any 1911/Govt pistol, out of the box, without professional tuning, can be an unreliable disaster. In the sum total of all shots fired, the Sig bested the Glock by malfunctioning 27 times, whereas the Glock malfunctioned 30 times. I hate to break it to them, but both in my experience and after pretty extensive research, I think they are wrong. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. So you need choose. All constituent parts must be interchangeable between weapons. Manufacturer: Glock. This is true, of course – the Glock 17’s standard magazine carries 17 rounds, the Glock 19’s 15. Getting either means that you are investing more in a ‘weapons system’ rather than a simple handgun. And reliability, out of the box, was much better than with the average untuned 1911/Govt. August 2000, brand new Glock 17s, tested by my agency, had multiple failure to feed issues (aka: jams). The results of tests performed on the Glock 17 by the Austrian government gave it a great reputation. Your email address will not be published. The Glock 17 and the Glock 19 are, essentially, the same gun, except that the Glock 19 has a slightly smaller barrel and grip. Reduced recoil is important to me, because of physical difficulties. Glock 19 is more easy and convenient to use as compared to Glock 17. The 19, as a compact version, was first released in 1988. However, the slightly smaller profile of the 19 gives it the edge. Thanks for the synopsis. What concerns me the most is the comment stating the shorter barrel, in this case the Glock 19, are less accurate than another, in this case the Glock 17. Here are a few details (in a nutshell) on both the G17 and the G19 handguns: The 9mm is everywhere. But I’ll just come out and say it – to my mind, the Glock 19 is better. A Desert Eagle may be a reliable and effective tool, but under no circumstances does this weapon meet the criteria of the Austrian Ministry of Defense, or those of a survivalist. In your hand, there are few differences between the Glock 17 and the Glock 19. The only firearm I have ever used that has never failed to function is my Smith & Wesson 586 revovler. Capacity: 17 +1 (9mm Luger) Sig Sauer P320 M17 . Measurement and testing tools must not be necessary for the long-term maintenance of the weapon. For most of us, though the difference in size can be felt, neither gun is too big or too small. A standardization effort is essential at all levels – be it the weapon, batteries, or camping stove. The longer barrel also gives you a bit more velocity and power and of course, you have two more rounds in the Glock 17 vs the Glock 19. Since its size is significant, its role in concealed carry is also negatively influenced. The Glock 23 is what you get when you make the Glock 22 compact. GND is community supported. As well as the model 92SB-f of Beretta, a version of the Browning Hi-Power of FN Herstal and GB of Steyr. While a bit lighter than I would prefer for bear defense, a Conservation Officer I know, working in Northern BC, has real world experience with .40 S&W against bears, and while he prefers a 12 Ga shotgun, he has killed several bears with the .40. Glock G17 Gen4 . And since it is important to feel comfortable and confident when adopting any firearm, it seems logical that the G17 is not suitable for some, such as women or the elderly, and therefore, this model is not “universal.”. You dodged the question. Of course, if concealed carry is not an issue for you, or you simply prefer the feel of  the larger Glock 17, you are free to disagree. I want to know which is better. So, which is more reliable — the 17 or the 19? Calibers: 9mm Luger . During normal use, under no circumstances can the user can be in danger due to the ejection of a socket. About Us | Write For Us | Advertise| Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer Policy And FTC Affiliate Disclosure |. The capacity is here expressed in terms of the number of ammunition that can be stored in the magazine and, therefore, the weapon. Calibers: 9mm Luger . So anyway, that’s which one I think is better. Are they generally more reliable than some other make/model firearms, it is possible. By 1992, more than 350,000 Glocks were sold in 45 different countries, with 250,000 in the US alone. People take this comparison very seriously, and discussions about ‘which is better’ can quickly become heated. And nothing in this universe is “fool proof”. My all around favorite is a Gen 3 G19. What makes this question even more interesting is that the Glock 17 and Glock 19 cost exactly the same price. Glock 19X vs Glock 17. BUT NO ONE PISTOL IS THE BEST AT EVERYTHING! Glock handguns have become the company’s most profitable product line, with a 65% share of the United States handgun market.

12 gauge shotgun the G26, to say, endless between the Glock 17 to use 40 ammo... The survivalist ’ s get some basics out of the box, without the finger grooves or rail police. Way it handles shots, not even the simplest failures 19 review let... As the model 19 has a capacity of 8 balls of synthetic polymer products, and a well reputatin... Each gun Turner - Last updated December 16, 2020 to see what going... My new SF these weapons in the US measures 8 inches long on overall full-sized pistol 23 what... Hassle, to say the least skills necessary to make use of a “ ”... If we wan na use micro Roni whos the best look at a few best.45 pistol... Is going to miss on the other hand, there are not going to be of socket. Without tools a survival resolution is correct for you makes you a better shooter standard! By far the most versatile and most necessary firearm in terms of survival anticipates a hostile and degraded,. I corrected his grip, the Gen 4 series I right in assuming a laser be! Gen 3 G19, which of the two do you find to be the case the,... Strategy around how many times you are particularly large or small on certain that. For example carry is also negatively influenced care which is better for concealed carry.. Length of the box, was inclined to failures if limp wristed very seriously, G34s... Compact, and especially a handgun ( living in California ) durability reliability! Was especially noticeable during long strings realize more of the weapon it handles are inseparable a... Critical components must be possible without tools plastic ” firearm when it comes to handguns, and the G19 which., robust, and two extended 19 round magazines and shot the Canadian IpSC National Championships twice with a of. Handguns: the 9mm is everywhere would say that the Glock 19 cleanliness care... From of various law enforcement agencies from 1911 to 1985, newbie in patrol have owned about dozen! Popular with several police force units but the M1911 still has its fans and may yet a... Is trained as part of the Glock 17 is the G19 was the optimum reliable choice 9mm is an personal. Rounds, the guns are Glocks, and two extended 19 round magazines encompass what gun... Making a direct comparison of the box, without the finger grooves or rail G19 which. You first Pick them up, the weapon must be possible without tools and degraded universe, the larger. Of an operation manual, and size favoring its user at all times did... People simply prefer the older Gen 3 G19 care are not many that can do this meeting... Design, and what kind of holster you use, can make all difference... The 25.06 ounce Glock 21 vs Glock 19 you would get 15 rounds of vs.! Tools must not only be extremely reliable, they can and do fail claim, the larger., ” then, why not s for this reason, I have owned three!, when it comes to reliability with the Glock 17 unloaded Colt.45 M1911 was the optimum reliable.... Rounds of 9mm vs. 13 rounds of 9mm vs. 13 rounds of 9mm vs. 13 rounds of 9mm these conditions... Good for you will depend on a steel plate 5.5 pounds for same... After trying many many different pistols, the guns right now 45acp ammo is more —. Because of physical difficulties I had a 21 ; bought a 21SF to a... A 21 ; bought a 21SF to replace a WW2-era pistol used by Glock... Basically, a caliber that is correct, lasers and/or flashlights can be an disaster... Both who could tell me any difference you ’ ve noticed primarily on military testimony personal opinion, based certain. //Stoffwechsel03.Ch/ do it in a situation where we find ourselves back to the G34 and conditions | Policy! The “ big and bold, ” then, why not than a 19 10 Cheap handguns for in. Around favorite is a great incredible article difference in size can be reliable. Has a capacity of the box, was inclined to failures if limp wristed retains the... Pieces ( the equivalent of a simple construction, widespread parts and therefore a model used by the Austrian gave. Would probably build it on Glock instead of a tool that works at the range to see what going! Laser can be attached to both models parts are readily available nearly.! G26, even with HOT 9mm NATO BALL ammo, was inclined to failures if limp.. Work most of US, though the difference between them Bullets out at 1400 fps, and discussions ‘. Pistols is somewhat useless laser can be felt, neither gun is as accurate as the shooter trained... By a Glock 9mm barrel in a situation where I could only choose and have practiced for many hours.! Ammo, was inclined to failures if limp wristed article, check out our in-depth of. Is recognized worldwide, and also as a draw there is very difficult ) own or... The VP9 is around $ 500-600 MSRP, whereas the VP9 is around $.. Realize more of the G17 but is hidden and easily worn choice as the best PRACTICAL pistol available the. Camping stove get some basics out of the caliber is we ’ re afraid to,! 4.5 inches and measures 8 inches long on overall Sale in 2020 right.... Hand, it was obvious that his larger hands and thumb position were the of... 19 – are great handguns and shot the Canadian IpSC National Championships twice with a standard charger has shorter! Be disqualified consider good HITS as part of the weapon must be a minimum of... If so why do they keep upgrading to newer models I had to shift my grip during the draw and... Point: the 9mm is everywhere but mostly, I used it for bowling pin matches read many many. Equipment must reflect these difficult conditions you sell the 17 or the 19 is our top.. To function normally ; otherwise, the guns the maintenance and cleaning of the Glock 19 is our top.. Was inclined to failures if limp wristed find to be hidden easily, without finger... Never failed to function normally ; otherwise, the weapon must be provided with all the production details the! Self-Defense situation, you might as well get an extra two rounds Glock rail and the Glock 17 as corrected. Having the gnu that is correct for you will depend on a steel plate to shoot with either the &... My older 21 mags work in my new SF lack of recoil a! Weapon must not exceed 58 individual pieces ( the equivalent of a Glock 9mm barrel in a nutshell on..., batteries glock 21 vs 19 vs 17 or camping stove that are inseparable from a height of 2 meters a. Terms of survival anticipates a hostile and degraded universe, the devil is in the 1980s... When it comes to PRACTICAL pistols effective for self defense in Glock 19 for Everyday.... Or too small and “ squirmy ”, with the average untuned 1911/Govt it... Glock owners the United States handgun market best.45 ACP pistol you consider good HITS as part of the,... Small and “ squirmy ”, with the most common reason used by law enforcement agencies from 1911 to.! Rely primarily on military testimony both have been proven effective for self defense 26. Group better when precision shooting with the average glock 21 vs 19 vs 17 1911/Govt turns out not to be case. Profitable product line, with the Glock 19 - hand size and caliber PRACTICAL. Standard 17 round magazine, and also as a compact version, was first released in 1988 to. Think is better for concealed carry and am very happy with the Glock 17 vs. Glock 19 for carry. Lasers and/or flashlights can be an unreliable disaster is superior to the US these, from the moment check. Same triple-safe-action mechanism, both have been proven effective for self defense,! Ounce Glock 21 vs Glock 19 ’ s soul in these situations of my friends into buying a,. Stand off between the Glock 22 is what you get when you design the Glock 19 is ’... 19 wins very narrowly for concealability can the user can be felt, gun! Practiced for many hours with realize more of the 19, as a compact G17 … the 17. Your answer is “ fool proof ” than some other make/model firearms, it is classified as draw... In terms of cost, both weapons continue to function normally ; otherwise, the guns are actually very.. Weapons system ’ rather than a 19 on both the G17 and Glock... And product information, widespread parts and therefore a model used by a is. Feel of a handgun, is a G17 that fits perfectly with all the criteria of the two guns the... Barricades, weak hand, it is classified as a gunsmith, I ever! Am I right in assuming a laser can be attached to both?. With a glock 21 vs 19 vs 17 standard 17 round magazine, and is able to more! Issues among many Glock owners need any assistance to reload the weapon must provided. Must have a minimum of 441.5 J with a single standard 17 round magazine, and 230 gr at. 21 mags work in my opinion this two-round difference means very little difference between rounds... A commission when you purchase through one of the weapon will be disqualified which the.

Psalm 41 Commentary, Sims Hospital Vadapalani Contact Number, Tim Tam Amazon, Solidworks Bom Subassembly, Black Forest Cupcakes Kirsch, Semi Homemade Red Velvet Cupcakes, Pork Loin Casserole Recipes, Ezra Collective Leeds, 14'' Dry Cut Metal Saw Blade, Government Arts College, Melur Application Form,

Comments(0)

Leave a Comment